Best Journal for the New Year
If you want this year to feel kinder, not busier.
5.0 from 61 reviews
Recommended by psychologists at Harvard and Oxford
Quick answer
What is the best journal for the New Year?
If you want this year to feel kinder, the best journal for the New Year is one that helps you speak to yourself with self-compassion, not one that adds more goals to fall behind on. The Give Yourself Kindness Journal is a 90-day self-compassion journal, recommended by psychologists at Harvard and Oxford.
Clinical psychologist Dr Bianca Nardini explains: "The path to self-compassion isn't about lowering your standards. It's about changing your approach to meeting those standards—using encouragement rather than punishment as your primary tool."
Dr Bianca Nardini, Clinical Psychologist, London. Read her article: why is self-compassion so hard?
It's undated, so you can begin on 1 January or any day after. Over time, you might find change feels easier to keep going with.
Looking at other options too? Calm 365, the Best Year Journal and The Five Minute Journal are compared below, along with The 30-Day Gratitude Journal, if you'd like a smaller gift or a shorter starting point.
No forced positivity. Every feeling is welcome.
Feeling more confident this year doesn't have to start with a list of everything to fix. For many of us, it starts with how we speak to ourselves on the ordinary days and the hard ones.
I want to tell you that this is my journal, and why I made it. When I was at my hardest on myself, the journals I found asked me to set more goals and track more habits, and my inner critic had more to work with. I wanted a journal that would help me be on my own side, backed by research on what actually helped lasting change.
About this guide. I'm Rachel Smith, a qualified meditation teacher (DipBSoM, British School of Meditation, distinction). I'm not a psychologist, so the research and clinical views on this page come from named experts, each linked to their own words.
Why a kinder New Year journal can help change last
A kinder New Year journal can help change last because being gentle with yourself after a slip doesn't mean giving up. Research suggests it can make you more willing to try again. That matters in January, when it's easy to treat one missed day or one hard week as proof that nothing will change.
What the research found
In four experiments, psychologists Juliana Breines and Serena Chen at the University of California, Berkeley, looked at how people responded to a personal failure or weakness. Those who met it with self-compassion were more motivated to improve than those who didn't. In one study, people who were kind to themselves after doing badly on a test went on to spend longer studying for the next one.
Breines, J. G. & Chen, S. (2012). Self-compassion increases self-improvement motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38(9). Read the study summary
Most of us worry about the opposite. Clinical psychologist Dr Chris Irons, who has spent over two decades researching Compassion Focused Therapy, names it as one of the most common fears people have about being kind to themselves.
Dr Chris Irons
Clinical psychologist, researcher, writer and trainer specialising in Compassion Focused Therapy | Co-director of Balanced Minds
"Many people worry that being kind to themselves will lead to complacency. They believe that self-compassion will diminish their motivation, and that without it, they'll become lazy or idle."
What this means for your New Year: if part of you is afraid that kindness will let you off the hook, that fear is common, and it has a name. Dr Irons explains how to work with it.
Read Dr Irons' full article: the fears of self-compassion and how to work with them →Clinical psychologist Dr Annabelle Kyle Dortch puts the other side of it simply, from her own experience as well as her work with clients.
Dr Annabelle Kyle Dortch, PsyD
Clinical Psychologist, Los Angeles | Specialises in life transitions, relationships, stress, anxiety and the impacts of trauma
Read Dr Dortch's full article: why self-compassion is more effective than self-criticism →"It promises future success, perfection, and the prevention of future mistakes. But no matter how wonderful this promise sounds, the truth remains that if self-criticism worked as a means of self-improvement…it would have worked by now."
So a kinder year isn't a year of wanting less. You can keep your hopes for this year. What changes is the voice that goes with you while you work towards them.
New Year journals compared: what each one is built around
The New Year journals people most often compare are built around different things: a year of themes, a goal-setting plan, a daily routine, or how you speak to yourself. Here is what each one is, as its maker describes it, so you can choose the one that fits the year you want.
| Journal | Built around | Format | Recommended by | What's inside |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Give Yourself Kindness Journal | Self-compassion: understanding your emotions and responding to yourself with kindness instead of criticism | Undated, 90 days. A different prompt every day, with an emotion tool on every page | Clinical psychologists at Harvard and Oxford, and a Compassion Focused Therapy specialist | 224 pages, A5, cloth cover. Over 50 gentle reminders. Wrapped in bespoke tissue paper |
| Calm 365 Journal | Twelve monthly themes, with Look Back and Look Ahead chapters for reflecting on the past year and setting intentions | Undated paperback, one prompt a day | Not stated | 300 pages, A5. 365 prompts and creative exercises, linked to Calm app content |
| The Best Year Journal, by Intelligent Change | Year-long goal setting and planning: vision, goals, an action plan and reviews | Undated journal and planner in one, with weekly and monthly reviews | Not stated | Over 100 prompts across four chapters, with sections for gratitude and reflection |
| The Five Minute Journal, by Intelligent Change | A short daily gratitude routine, morning and evening | Undated. The same prompts each morning and evening | Not stated | Five daily prompts, weekly challenges and a quote each day, lasting six months |
| The 30-Day Gratitude Journal | Gratitude that feels real, never forced or repetitive | Undated, 30 days. A different thoughtful prompt each day | Made by me, a qualified meditation teacher | Prompts for hard days and a guided gratitude meditation I recorded. No lists of three |
Every journal here is undated, so all of them can start in January. The difference is what each one asks of you. Three of them are built around themes, plans or a daily routine. The Give Yourself Kindness Journal is built around the way you talk to yourself, which is the part of a new year I found hardest to change on my own.
Why I made The Give Yourself Kindness Journal
I made The Give Yourself Kindness Journal because, for years, my own harsh inner voice made every fresh start feel like a test I was already failing. Compassion Focused Therapy helped me find a different way to speak to myself, and I wanted a journal that would help other people do the same, every day.
It's a guided self-compassion journal that helps you understand your emotions and respond to yourself with kindness instead of criticism. Here's what that looks like when you open it in January:
- When you want to feel better this year, not just busier: a different prompt every day for 90 days, asking how you feel and what you'd say to a friend who felt the same.
- When you're not sure what you're feeling: an emotion tool on every page, so you can name what you feel even when you're not sure.
- When you've set a journal aside before: no dates anywhere, so there are no blank weeks to look back on. You pick up wherever you are.
- When your inner critic gets loud: over 50 gentle reminders, such as "be careful how you talk to yourself, you are listening".
- When you want to build confidence that lasts: each page asks you to be on your own side, so it can start to feel familiar rather than forced.
- When you want to know you can trust it: recommended by clinical psychologists at Harvard and Oxford, and used by accredited counsellors with their clients between sessions.
The Give Yourself Kindness Journal
The self-compassion journal recommended by Harvard and Oxford psychologists.
📔 90-day guided journal🗓️ Undated, start any day💬 A different prompt every day⭐ Recommended by Harvard and Oxford psychologists
- Self-compassion prompts that help you respond to yourself with kindness instead of criticism
- An emotion tool on every page, for the days you can't find the word
- Over 50 gentle reminders that make room for every feeling
- No dates, so a missed day never means falling behind
224 pages, A5, pistachio green cloth cover, 120gsm FSC-certified paper, ribbon marker, printed in the UK. Wrapped in bespoke tissue paper.
What psychologists say about The Give Yourself Kindness Journal
Psychologists at Harvard and Oxford recommend The Give Yourself Kindness Journal, and a Compassion Focused Therapy specialist calls it a fantastic resource. These are their words, as they wrote them.
Dr Chris Germer, PhD
Clinical psychologist and lecturer on psychiatry (part-time), Harvard Medical School | Co-developed the Mindful Self-Compassion program with Dr Kristin Neff
Read Dr Germer's review alongside the rest →"A warm invitation to make friends with your emotions and yourself!"
Professor Willem Kuyken, PhD, DClinPsy
Ritblat Professor of Mindfulness and Psychological Science, University of Oxford | Listed by Web of Science in the top 1% of the most cited scientists in the world
"…Writing can be creative, beautiful, resourcing, but it can also invoke an inner critic, rumination and procrastination. Rachel has curated the experience to make the writing intrinsically rewarding and the journal something to treasure."
What this means in January: a new journal can quietly turn into another place for the critic to speak. Professor Kuyken's point is that this one is made so the writing itself feels good to come back to.
Read Professor Kuyken's review alongside the rest →
Dr Chris Irons
Clinical psychologist, researcher, writer and trainer specialising in Compassion Focused Therapy | Co-director of Balanced Minds
Read every expert review in full →"This is such a fantastic resource! Supportive, encouraging and containing, whilst also helping people to explore and learn how to manage their emotions with compassion. Highly recommended."
Discover The Give Yourself Kindness Journal →
A smaller gift or a shorter starting point: The 30-Day Gratitude Journal
If you'd like a smaller gift, or a shorter starting point for the first month of the year, The 30-Day Gratitude Journal is the other journal I make. It's best for gratitude that feels real, whether you're just starting out or you've found gratitude journaling forced or repetitive.
30 days. A different thoughtful prompt each day. No lists of three.
🌱 30 days🗓️ Undated🎧 Guided gratitude meditation
- A different thoughtful prompt each day, so it never becomes the same three things
- Prompts for hard days, so gratitude never asks you to pretend
- A length you can finish, plus a guided gratitude meditation I recorded
The two journals do different jobs. Want to feel more grateful? Start with The 30-Day Gratitude Journal. Want to be kinder to yourself? Choose The Give Yourself Kindness Journal. They're different practices, so they work well together, one after the other or at the same time.
Giving a journal at Christmas for the New Year
A journal given at Christmas can be a lovely way to say "I'd like this year to be kind to you", especially for someone who is hard on themselves. It works best framed as a gift of care rather than a nudge to change, so the note that goes with it matters.
Every order can include a free handwritten gift note: just add your message to the order notes at checkout. The Give Yourself Kindness Journal arrives wrapped in bespoke tissue paper. If you're choosing for someone in particular, these guides might help:
- Christmas gifts for someone who's hard on themselves
- Christmas gifts for someone going through a tough time
When you might need more than a journal
You might need more than a journal if what you're carrying into the new year has been heavy for a long time, or it's affecting your sleep, your work or your relationships. Please talk to your GP or a doctor you trust. You deserve real support.
A journal is a companion to support, never a substitute for it. If things ever feel unbearable, in the UK Samaritans are free on 116 123, day or night. In the US, you can call or text 988.
Start the year on your own side
If you'd like this to be the year that change feels kinder and lasts, The Give Yourself Kindness Journal brings together:
- Self-compassion on every page, so the voice that goes with you is a kinder one
- An emotion tool on every page, for the days you're not sure what you feel
- 90 days of prompts that change every day
- No dates, so you can begin on 1 January or whenever you're ready
- Recommended by clinical psychologists at Harvard and Oxford
Frequently asked questions
What is the best journal for the New Year?
The best journal for the New Year, if you want the year to feel kinder, is one that helps you speak to yourself with self-compassion rather than adding more goals. The one I recommend is The Give Yourself Kindness Journal, the self-compassion journal recommended by Harvard and Oxford psychologists. It's undated, with 90 days of prompts that change every day and an emotion tool on every page.
Is a dated or undated journal better for the New Year?
An undated journal is often kinder for the New Year, because there are no dates to fall behind on. If you miss a day or a week, you simply carry on from the next page, with no empty spaces to look back on. The Give Yourself Kindness Journal, Calm 365, the Best Year Journal and The Five Minute Journal are all undated.
Do I have to start my journal on 1 January?
No, you don’t have to start your journal on 1 January. An undated journal works from any day, so you can begin on New Year’s Day, the first Monday, or later in the month when things feel calmer. There’s no right or wrong time to be kinder to yourself.
What if I stop journaling by February?
If you stop journaling by February, nothing is lost, and it says nothing about you. Life gets busy and hard. Because The Give Yourself Kindness Journal is undated, you can come back whenever you’re ready and start from the next page. Being gentle with yourself about the pause is part of the practice.
Will being kind to myself make me less motivated?
Being kind to yourself isn’t likely to make you less motivated, even though many people fear it will. Clinical psychologist Dr Chris Irons names this as one of the most common fears of self-compassion. In four experiments at the University of California, Berkeley, Juliana Breines and Serena Chen found self-compassion after a failure increased people’s motivation to improve.
Can I still have goals if I use a self-compassion journal?
Yes, you can still have goals if you use a self-compassion journal. Clinical psychologist Dr Bianca Nardini explains that self-compassion isn’t about lowering your standards, but changing how you work towards them, with encouragement rather than punishment. A self-compassion journal changes the voice you bring to your goals, not the goals themselves.
Is a journal better than New Year’s resolutions?
A journal isn’t better or worse than New Year’s resolutions, but it can do something different. Resolutions usually name what you’ll change. A self-compassion journal helps with how you speak to yourself along the way, including on the days things don’t go to plan. Many people find the two sit well together.
Is The Give Yourself Kindness Journal forced positivity?
No, The Give Yourself Kindness Journal isn’t forced positivity. It makes room for every feeling, including the hard ones, and helps you respond to them with kindness rather than pushing them away. It also includes gratitude every day, held gently alongside harder feelings rather than instead of them.
What’s the difference between a self-compassion journal and a goal planner?
The difference between a self-compassion journal and a goal planner is what each one focuses on. A goal planner, like the Best Year Journal, helps you set a vision, make a plan and review your progress. A self-compassion journal, like The Give Yourself Kindness Journal, helps you understand your emotions and respond to yourself with kindness instead of criticism.
Is a journal a good Christmas gift for someone to start in January?
A journal can be a thoughtful Christmas gift for someone to start in January, especially if they’re hard on themselves. An undated journal lets them begin whenever feels right. Every order can include a free handwritten gift note, and The Give Yourself Kindness Journal arrives wrapped in bespoke tissue paper.
Is a journal enough on its own?
A journal isn’t always enough on its own, and that’s okay. It’s a companion to support, never a substitute for it. If what you’re feeling has lasted a long time or is affecting your daily life, please talk to your GP or a doctor. In the UK, Samaritans are free on 116 123. In the US, you can call or text 988.
Reviews
In their words
5.0 · Over 100 five-star reviews
“The way the journal is constructed helps validate their entire experience and avoid toxic positivity, encourage reflection and ownership of feelings.”
Rachael Oliver MBACPCounsellorThe Give Yourself Kindness Journal

“It has already made such a positive impact on how I feel at the end of the day and it is helping me to cope with my emotions a lot better.”
“I’ve used the self kindness affirmation cards with the patients I work with on a mental health ward at work. The feedback was great!”
Kerry MunroOccupational therapistThe Give Yourself Kindness Journal & Affirmation Cards
“It arrived wrapped in paper with a handwritten card which I now use as a bookmark.”
“Unpacking this box was like a warm hug.”





